Now
Fair
67°
High
86°
Low
66°

Brissa's story highlights troubled system

Text Size: 
Tools Sponsor

Friday, Jul 07, 2006 - 12:12:18 am CDT

The Journal Star’s six-part serial “A Home for Brissa” gave readers a look inside the process for legal immigrants. It was an eye-opener.

The system is overloaded, sluggish and Byzantine. Its complexity makes it mystifying. Immigration reform cannot ignore its shortcomings.

As the serial written by Cindy Lange-Kubick depicted, Brissa’s case was special in some ways.

Brissa entered the United States illegally as child, brought here by her mother. Later Brissa was adopted by Jessica and Jason Placek of Wilber. That wasn’t enough to make her legal. She still needed to find a way through the snarl of red tape to stay with her adopted family.

But Brissa’s story also was typical of the problems that would-be legal immigrants face.

At the U.S. Consulate in Juarez, Mexico, where Brissa eventually got her visa, the average wait for spouses and children of U.S. citizens to get their visa interview is 18 months to three years. A sister or brother of a U.S. citizen would have to wait 10 to 12 years.

The delays at Juarez are found throughout the system. U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services in April had more than 420,000 immigration applications that had been waiting more than six months to be processed. The Labor Department, which also processes immigration cases, has a backlog of 235,000 cases, some of which date back five or six years.

The problems are not reserved solely for the poor and unskilled immigrants. Brilliant and educated workers also encounter frustrating delays. “I truly think if Albert Einstein were in my office in 2006, he would be saying, ‘I’m going to Canada rather than wait any longer,’” immigration attorney Judy Bourdeau of Kansas City told the Associated Press.

Brissa was lucky to have the indomitable Jessica as her advocate. Jessica burrowed through the complexity, and found a helpful expert in Max Grave, and a powerful ally in Sen. Chuck Hagel.

After months of uncertainty, hundreds of hours of research and thousands of dollars, Brissa finally got her green card, and in short order her Social Security card. She’s now a legal resident of the United States.

Her story illustrates, however, the frustration and difficulties that await those who get in line for legal immigration status.

Improvement in that process is urgent. The system ought to be easy to understand. Decisions should be fair and rational. Routine applications should be processed in a timely fashion.

If Congress is serious about reducing the number of illegal immigrants in the country, one of the most important things it can do is show some respect for the immigrants who want to do the right thing.


$1 Sunday Delivery - Subscribe Today!
Editorial Main > Back to Top of Story

All posts to JournalStar.com are subject to our Terms and Standards.
Your posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
Frequently asked questions about story commenting.
(optional)
   
Gary B wrote on July 7, 2006 8:40 am:
" I feel for those legal immigrants who undergo a long, arduous process to gain citizenship, but the difficulty of the process is not justification for entering the country legally. Immigrants, show me how bad you want to be an American citizen, don't just do a little run, swim, and jump. Entering illegally only shows me that you're here to make money and steal from our government, and have no interest in ever becoming a legal citizen. "

Josh wrote on July 7, 2006 8:58 am:
" I think everybody can agree that the system is flawed and needs reform. My wife came here legally from China about 3 years ago, and to get her fiancee visa (the visa that simply allows her to enter the US) took 11 months. During that 11 months we had A LOT of paperwork to submit, and I must admit it was quite confusing. After arriving here and getting married, we then had to apply for permanent residence (green card)- that process took about 13 or 14 months. After getting the green card, it's a 5 year wait before being able to apply for citizenship (if she'd like to). I understand how frustrating the process is, but even my wife will say (very strongly) that this is no excuse for people to come here illegally- in fact she thinks those who come here illegally are a shame, a "kick in the pants" to everyone else who takes the time to come the legal way. "

sose wrote on July 9, 2006 12:59 pm:
" the waiting process can be a pain in the butt, but it is a matter of how bad do u want it. however, as far as the "American Dream" goes, those who will contribute to our economy and make good citizens lose a lot of time, while we have illigals just crossing the border every day. our immigration system needs to be reformed real fast. reformed for legals not for illigals. reforming a reform for illegals will only bring more illegals. a U.S. citizen should not wait for years for his/her family memeber to join him/her, when an illegal just breaks our laws and receives amnesty. that is just wrong. families should be reunited first, borders secured next, then maybe illegals, even then illegals are illegals period. "

SM wrote on July 9, 2006 7:33 pm:
" I came to the USA 2nd Jan 1994 on a student visa to do MS Engineering. Passed that with flying colors. Immediately after MS engineering, I joined a multinational based in the USA. Since that day I am maintaining my H1B visa. Now trapped in retrogression. In the mean time my widfe finished her BBA accounting from a US university. As she is my visa dependent she can not work in the USA. My children were in grade 5th and 3rd at that time, next year older one is graduating from top notch US university, but if I do not get green card till then he will not be able to work here. Well, it appears to me that system is all flawed, favors only system beaters and illegals...so 13 years in the USa and still counting. "

rich wrote on July 11, 2006 10:38 am:
" yes, brissa's story does tell of a troubled system - but it doesn't give anybody the right to alter the laws for anyone at anytime - hagel needs to be held accountable for this - "

c.h. wrote on July 12, 2006 1:02 pm:
" All I'm certain of, concerning immigration reform, is that we need some. It's such a complex problem, and I wish us all luck. Having said that,I have a question that I truly want answered, hopefully by some members of the hispanic community. I mean no disrepect!This may not be the place for this question, but lacking a better forum.... Why all the push for everyone to allow special consideration for the spanish-speaking only people. My grandparents all came from overseas, and learned to speak english. English is a second language for both my parents. I have latvian friends who learned english upon coming here. All the asians I know have made the effort. Is it a matter of the number of people? is there a resistance on matter of principal? Maybe there would be less resistance to reforms if so many people didn't perceive a resistance to learn english as an unwillingness to meld into America.s diverse society. Thoughts anyone? Also, raeding the comments here, does everyone remember that Brissa was a child when she was brought here, and as such, had absolutely no say in the matter? I would think your objections would only apply to autonomous adults. "

tn wrote on July 12, 2006 4:44 pm:
" I found Brissa's journey through our governmental maze to be very educational. Adoption laws, citizenship requirements, so much paperwork! Chuck Hagel and Max Grave were the right resources for the Placek family. Congratulations and best wishes to the Placek family. And thank you Cindy for another "enlightening" series. "

cheryl wrote on September 5, 2007 2:23 pm:
" When do we hold Mexico (President Fox) accountable for not taking care of their own people? The richest man in the world lives in Mexico.I would prefer to help not carry this burden. "